Thursday, May 20, 2010

Why Blumenthal but not Kirk?

A note to NBC Chicago blog readers: I am not an Illinois blogger. To say I am seems to suggest I have a dog in your political fight. While I lean left politically, my dislike for people who b.s. about their military service, not politics, led me to begin reporting on Mark Kirk. I had no idea how many lies there were to be found. -Terry, 03JUN10

In 2005, a political tussle in Ohio led to Rep. Jean Schmidt claiming that Rep. Mark Kirk (who's currently running for Barack Obama's former Senate seat) was a "veteran of Operation Iraqi Freedom." It was news to me that any politician had served in Iraq by that time and, as it turned out, it wasn't true. Mark Kirk was claiming on his campaign site to be "the only member of Congress to serve stateside during Operation Iraqi Freedom," which was true, but on his official web site he claimed to be "the only member of Congress to serve in Operation Iraqi Freedom." To say you have served in a campaign is precisely the sort of falsehood for which Richard Blumenthal has been castigated for the past few days.

Yet, whereas Blumenthal repeatedly pointed out in speeches that he had served "during" Vietnam--with that noteable slip-up--and then corrected the record when the mistake was pointed out, Kirk's office refused to address the falsehood on his web site for more than 50 days after I first contacted him, despite the fact the Navy's Office of Information agreed that, because Kirk had never served in Iraq during Iraqi Freedom, he had no right to claim to be an Iraqi Freedom veteran.

In the end, Kirk's staff simply changed the site without comment or apology.

As a veteran of the Afghanistan Campaign myself, I find it disgusting when people make claims to service they haven't earned. I do believe, having watched the debate over Blumenthal's claim unfold, that the Connecticut Attorney General said "in" when he meant "during." He had even correctly described his service earlier in the same speech. Kirk, on the other hand, made a false claim and then refused to correct it for more than a month after it was discovered, despite repeated contact on my part. That is conduct unbecoming an officer.

And yet, I have been making phone calls to members of the media today, including to producers of Chris Matthews, who have refused to speak to me about the issue. This despite the fact Matthews has been hammering Blumenthal for days now, including saying the following:
  • "...don't (Democrats) have to drop this candidate and get another one?"

  • "The reports were out there that he had served in Vietnam the Marine Corps, he never corrected the record."

  • "He may be, uh, have a real problem with character and the truth, but anyone who helps him become a senator is to me beyond the pale at this point."
Well, Mr. Matthews, by refusing to shine as bright a light on Kirk's direct, stubborn attempt to misrepresent his service--and his failure to apologize for doing so--you are helping a much worse liar than Blumenthal become a senator.

I am awaiting a statement by Hardball producers explaining their reluctance to cover this issue.

Update: It seems Kirk has been obfuscating about his military career for some time.

Update: I received an e-mail which pointed out that Kirk had "deployed" to Afghanistan while in office. Let me call bullshit on that, too. Kirk, it seems, found a way to perform his Annual Training periods in a war zone. Yes, I give him some credit for going over there in the first place, but, he is claiming he was on a "deployment" when he was merely performing his two-week-long bare minimum active duty requirement. The minimum deployment length for Sailors who aren't politically connected is 6-7 months and, for soldiers, a year. Kirk's service amounts to little more than padding his resume. (Update: More on this here.)

It is unlikely, also, that he received the Afghanistan Campaign Medal for his service, which, again, is something any "veteran" of the war should have.

I just spoke with Kirk's press secretary for answers to these questions as well as a copy of his Intelligence Officer of the Year citation. She promised a swift response.

Update: Still no word from Kirk's press secretary or Hardball producers.

Update: Here.


Blogger Ironwoodtree said...

I had some fun with the Wayback machine. In 2005 he claimed to have patrolled the no-fly zone. I wonder if that's correct.

9:36 AM  
Blogger Andy Martin said...

I am surprised that no one mentions I raised this issue during the recent primary election and ran radio ads statewide calling Kirk a military imposter and fraud. Kirk has a commission. That’s where the truth ends. See DOD letter at

Andy Martin

12:00 PM  
Blogger jgsf1987 said...

This is hardly surprising, and while I think you're right that Chris should drop his coverage of Blumenthal, I think he makes a clear point by saying that there's too many liars trying to make names for themselves.

9:50 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Chris Matthews, Mediawhore, did not serve."

12:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Articles are meaningful, and your blog is nice!
Cheap New Era Hat
Cheap Coogi Cap
Cheap Dolce Gabbana Cap
Cheap Abercrombie Fitch Cap
Wholesale LRG Cap
Wholesale Polo Cap
Wholesale Puma Cap
Wholesale Enyce Cap
Wholesale Bape Cap
Wholesale Gucci Cap
Wholesale louis vuitton cap
Wholesale Prada Cap
Wholesale Christian Audigier Cap
Wholesale G_Unit Cap
Wholesale Chanel Cap
Wholesale Ed Hardy Cap
Wholesale Diesel Cap
Wholesale Burberry hats
Wholesale Red Monkey Cap
Wholesale Gino Green Global Cap
Replica Nike Jordan Shoes

7:38 PM  
Blogger  said...

Arthritis means inflammation of jointsMicrosoft Office 2010csdxumei02 It is one of several Office 2010diseases commonly called rheumatism. Arthritis arises from many causes and it is treated in many various methodsMicrosoft Office 2007Arthritis has been classified as follows: - * Arthritis caused by infection.airOffice 2007Arthritis has been classified as follows: - * Arthritis caused by infection.airMicrosoft OfficeRheumatoid arthritis. * Degenerative arthritis. * Arthritis due to joint injuries.supra shoes Office 2007 keyArthritis originating from the nervous Office 2007 downloadRheumatoid arthritis and arthritis caused by rheumatic Office 2007 Professionalfever are classified as collagen disease. * Rheumatoid arthritis and degenerative nfl jerseysMicrosoft outlooktwo common types. Millions of men and women Microsoft outlook 2010are afflicted with them. But good treatment begun early and continued faithfully can often do much to alleviate the pain

2:19 AM  
Blogger mewmewmew said...

It’s been said that the difference between the truth and fiction is that fiction has to make sense. After its third season, Battlestar Galactica steadily failed on both counts.

london escort
adult webcam chat

11:34 AM  
Anonymous it detachering said...

Interesting question to ask on Blumenthan and Kirk. Thanks for sharing.

10:25 AM  
Anonymous iphone 5 said...

This is a great blog. thanks for providing this info. You have so much knowledge about this.
thanks for sharing…
iphone 5

2:10 AM  
Anonymous iPhone Developer said...

You have so much knowledge about this.Thanks for sharing.

2:14 AM  
Anonymous iPhone Development said...

I think he makes a clear point by saying that there's too many liars trying to make names for themselves.

1:13 AM  
Anonymous Buy Lexapro Online said...

Thanks for a nice share you have given to us with such an large collection of information. Great work you have done by sharing them to all. simply superb.

6:27 AM  
Anonymous Latest Video Releases said...

I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it up! I'll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later. Many thanks Effects Of Smoking.

12:13 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home