Friday, June 25, 2010

Weak

Unnamed sources in the Pentagon are going after Rolling Stone.
...the command has concluded from its own review of events that McChrystal was betrayed when the journalist quoted banter among the general and his staff, much of which they thought was off the record. They contend that the magazine inaccurately depicted the attribution ground rules for the interviews.

"Many of the sessions were off-the-record and intended to give [reporter Michael Hastings] a sense" of how McChrystal's team operated, according to a senior military official. The command's own review of events, the official said, gleaned "no evidence to suggest" that any of the "salacious political quotes" in the article were made during a series of on-the-record and background interviews Hastings conducted with McChrystal and others.

The official, one of many subject to a Pentagon advisory not to discuss the situation without authorization, spoke on condition of anonymity. He said he was motivated by what he described as untrue claims made by Rolling Stone.

Two others with direct knowledge of the command's dealings with Hastings offered similar accounts.
This is bullshit. Journalism is not a game of Red Light/Green Light. There doesn't have to be "evidence" that the comments were made on the record because it doesn't work that way. If someone requests something to be off the record and the reporter uses it, that's a violation, but the subject doesn't have to say something's on the record for it to be used. I would say that goes double for embedded journalists.

I would also point out to the "officials" in the Pentagon that Army policy on this issue is explicit. As the Army Public Affairs Handbook puts it (pdf link):
Before beginning the interview, collect your thoughts, remind yourself of the ground rules, and remember there is no such thing as “off the record.” (Bold in the original.)
The handbook also has a message for the staffers who couldn't keep their mouths in check.
Set the ground rules with the reporter. Tell him you can talk about what your unit does, and its mission, minus details that compromise OPSEC. Remind him not to ask you to speculate about the future or answer questions outside your area of responsibility. (Stay in your lane).
And, I would add, Don't speak for the general.

The Pentagon "officials" are also complaining the Rolling Stone fact-checker didn't ask about the most damning quotes in Hastings' article. Guess what? Hastings has said he was openly using a recorder for most of the conversations, so why would a fact-checker have to check on statements which were recorded?

As Hastings said after the fact, no one has come forth to defend McChrystal's statements. For someone in the Pentagon to decide to go after Hastings with this weakass crap is ridiculous.

P.S. Byron York v. Michael Hastings.

3 Comments:

OpenID Lauren--NY said...

Excellent. Thank you for this.

5:13 PM  
Blogger  said...

Arthritis means inflammation of jointsMicrosoft Office 2010csdxumei02 It is one of several Office 2010diseases commonly called rheumatism. Arthritis arises from many causes and it is treated in many various methodsMicrosoft Office 2007Arthritis has been classified as follows: - * Arthritis caused by infection.airOffice 2007Arthritis has been classified as follows: - * Arthritis caused by infection.airMicrosoft OfficeRheumatoid arthritis. * Degenerative arthritis. * Arthritis due to joint injuries.supra shoes Office 2007 keyArthritis originating from the nervous Office 2007 downloadRheumatoid arthritis and arthritis caused by rheumatic Office 2007 Professionalfever are classified as collagen disease. * Rheumatoid arthritis and degenerative nfl jerseysMicrosoft outlooktwo common types. Millions of men and women Microsoft outlook 2010are afflicted with them. But good treatment begun early and continued faithfully can often do much to alleviate the pain

2:10 AM  
Blogger linksnz said...

Young pandora bracelets people need you can expect you pandora bracelets canada are likely to encounter these classy up-to-date pandora bracelets prices The warm season comes pandora bracelet 2011 draw ovoids in shops this pandora bracelets sale specific coming The spring. Typically charms maintains a handful of foundation ray ban sunglasses canada gives out relevant to brand new lure cheap pandora bracelets earrings, New season combined with Autumn, utilizing own personal The warm season comes let go oftentimes seeing to achieve the exact additional cheap pandora charms vital related with the main a couple of.

There can pandora jewelry canada be additionally interest given at other pandora charms cheap times over summer and winter. For example, now many pandora charms canada brand new enameled work surface cheap pandora charms ovoids happen to be earlier produced, and be able to just a little early, nevertheless some time immediately after often ray ban canada the september ovals, different absolutely new Murano cocoa beans Ray Ban Wayfarer. Routinely there is additionally ray ban sunglasses get a unique superb attraction presented so that you can dignity an exceptionally exclusive sunglasses canada holiday break.

12:13 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home